Monday, July 2, 2018

Black Bears and Brown Trout

The Farmington is over-rated. I know that opinion is probably going to piss a few people off, but hear me out. The Farmy has a decent macroinvertabrate population but it isn't anything special. I can't really think of a hatch that is uniquely great on the Farmington. Even less special is its baitfish life. Since the big Atlantic salmon fry stockings ended there has been a notable decrease in the size of the wild and holdover browns.What the Farmy does have in spades in tubers in the summer and way too many anglers all year round. The pressure this stream receives far exceeds it's quality.

I still fish the Farmington only for a handful of reasons: it does have some of largest wild brown trout in the state and it is a bottom draw tailwater that stays cold in the summer. A few days ago Mike Carl invited me out in the morning and I jumped on the opportunity. I don't often get up there early in the day and the chance to fish streamers and dries in some of my favorite water there before some idiot stepped on all the good lies, and that had me pretty certain of a good morning.

I started with dries in a shallow riffle with some rising fish. There were way too many bugs in and on and around the water to really pin down a specific hatch at the time so I went with an easy choice for non-selective risers: Sturdy's Fancy. Two small wild browns landed and a few missed later I was satisfied and ready to throw big streamers.


I moved up into some pocket water with what I call "good bank holds". A good bank hold has to be 1-4ft deep, have some shade nearby, some riffle, and moderate-fast current. These are the places I feel most confident will result in an aggressive take on a large streamer.
This time I got two very aggressive surface hits very quickly casting upstream into bank lies that I knew never had fish any other time I'd fished them. Why? Anglers had stood in them at some point during the day to nymph the pockets further out. Too many anglers still stand in the water they should be casting to.
Further up I hooked and landed a nice fat little brown, once again within feet of the bank.


I released that fish and then walked back up into position to work the next lie when I heard what I thought was another angler coming down to the water's edge. I was ready to reprimand somebody for thinking it was okay to jump in right next to me when there was easily 100 yards on either side of me with nobody fishing when I saw something black and fuzzy. It was a little bear, probably no more than 30 or 40lbs heavier than me, clearly very healthy. He popped out of the grass about 15 feet away, clearly oblivious to my presence. I said "Heeeey Bear!" and he calmly sauntered off. I kept fishing just as if he hadn't been there and caught another fat brown that stayed airborne for most of the fight.


I had pretty much exhausted the water I wanted to fish up there and so went down to the flat water where pods of trout were rising to little black caddis. It wasn't easy pickings, flat water never is, but we fooled a few before breakfast. 



8 comments:

  1. Ironically you just sold me on the Farmington ;-)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Good. As long as your expectations aren't unrealistic, fish it and enjoy.

      Delete
  2. I think your first paragraph, son, is pure ka-ka. As Senator Daniel Patrick Moynihan once said, "everyone is entitled to their own opinion but not their own facts".

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You can think what you want but you'd be hard pressed to change my mind. The hatch statement is based on fishing and learning about quite a few other famous rivers. The fact that salmon parr stocking reduction has appeared to effect trout size was bourn out by electrofishing. And when I catch trout with missing maximilary and see them refuse natural bugs, there's too much pressure. And I am far from the only person who has suggested this in the last couple years. If I could chose to live on any famous river in the NE the Farmy would be well down the list. I think a lot of anglers new to the Farmy have expectations of it that it just won't live up to. And hence, overated.

      Delete
    2. re: maxillary bones. Are you saying they are missing because of being torn off due to hooks?
      re: refusing natural bugs, you mean observing them turning away from actual real food? How do you assess this?
      I've only fished the Farmington 3 times. 1st time was a charmer in winter, caught a brown. Next two were skunkings.

      Delete
  3. I've probably caught a dozen trout om the Farmington with one maxillary bone missing and the other misshapen from repeated hookings. Put enough hooks through it, barbless or not, it will sustain some damage.
    Yes, I have visually observed on a few occasions Farmington trout rising to, inspecting, then refusing natural insects. I have seen the same thing on other heavily pressured water too.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I think I saw the same little bear on Saturday morning. We were heading down from MA on route 20 and the bear ran down a hill and almost right into my door. He put on the breaks and then proceeded to cross the road after we passed.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. It is at least possible, but there are so many bears in that area it could just as easily have been somebody else. Maybe even a sibling.

      Delete